Our suburban spaces give evidence of this greed in the proliferation of developments of what some wit has called McMansions, homes that are huge boxes sprawling into the countryside. Local landowners, many of whom are leading citizens, are only too happy to sell their families' farms and estates that lie on the edges of our cities. Those developments demand more shopping centers (heaven forbid that people who own two or three cars should have to use one of them to drive a few miles into the city to shop!) and lots of pavement.
San Luis Obisipo, California Chamber of Commerce photograph
The landowners and the developers wield enormous clout, and continue to obtain permits for their ever-expanding properties. Don't they ever look over their shoulders to see the mess they have left behind? At what point will we demand that they assume responsibility for the damage they've done as they press ever outward into what's left of our country?
I don't mean to imply that there's an easy answer to the problems of a burgeoning population. But when the private rights of a few trample on the community's right to clean air, clean water, and access to preserved esthetic spaces, surely the greater good should prevail.
So what can we do to enliven our cities and stop the sprawl? How long will it take us to learn that there's a difference between growth and improvement? Can we change that pioneering mindset? It will mean realizing that we need to stop building far afield, and start figuring out how to renovate or preserve what we have. If our downtown buildings aren't worth preserving, let's tear them down and build new ones on the same spot. The wise reuse of space already committed to commerce seems to me like a no-brainer.
It is painful to observe the failing shopping centers. The supermarkets are usually the first things to pull out. Their empty shells remain, paint faded and windows taped. They stand in large, mostly vacant parking lots, with perhaps a few small surrounding shops still open, shops whose owners are tied to leases or unable to afford higher rents. The centers that have been totally abandoned are the creepiest: a montage of peeling paint, broken windows, trash scattered about, parking lots that are used once a year for Christmas tree sales or charitable donation centers. They really do look like something from one of the rings of hell.
Alas, everyone seems to give lip service to the idea of city planning without following its precepts. In our area, a 40-acre tract of pines, old hardwoods, streams and a pond has just been destroyed by the bulldozers to make way for more offices and stores, right next to the "in" area of malls and roads, five miles from the city's center. Traffic there was already a nightmare; now, it will be a disaster.
It would be nice to think that our city Fathers could step back and observe the irrevocability of their actions. Once the trees are gone, they're gone. Once the land is graded, it's graded, that is unless someone is willing to spend considerably more than it cost to do the damage, to undo it. And a fat chance there is of that.
I know that there must be cities out there that have done a good job of urban renewal (San Luis Obispo, CA, comes to mind). Recently, the consultants for our latest downtown project have touted Memphis's Beale Street as something that our city should emulate. This seems to me to be a classic mistake, because what makes one area special doesn't necessarily transfer to another (and our area has a lively identity all its own). But at this point that's moot, because until we can stop the proliferation of those rings of hell, the shopping center syndrome with its pattern of build-and-abandon will ensure that any of our Downtown Revitalization plans have as much chance of success as an ice cube in you-know-where.
©2001 Julia Sneden for SeniorWomen.com
Pages: 1 · 2
More Articles
- PBS' Frontline Online: How Amazon Convinced Millions of People to Welcome “Listening Devices” Into Their Homes
- Return of House Flipping Eases Affordable Housing Crunch in Some States
- Getting Past It: Let’s Look for Ways to Serve Multiple Intelligences
- The Scout Report for a Spring Break: Loneliness; On Broadway; Biomedical Engineering; The Most Dangerous World Ever?; Killer Digital Libraries; Landscape Architecture; The Muse, a Free Job Hunting Service
- Catching Up on Your Fashion Education, Ladies: Revolutionary 3D Printing Technology
- A Perfect Weekend Diversion: New Sites From the Scout Report Including A Brief History of the Hashtag and Cyberbullying