Researchers Warn of Financial Risks in Retirement Jobs: Rethink Those SSA Benefit Calculations
Any of the 10,000 Baby Boomers retiring every day who are contemplating a second job in their retirement may want to reconsider, due to an unfamiliar network of federal and state taxes that can serve as significant work disincentives, advises a University of California, Berkeley, economist and professor of law and a team of fellow researchers.
In Is Uncle Sam Inducing the Elderly to Retire? a working paper published by the National Bureau of Economic Research, a team that includes Alan Auerbach, a UC Berkeley professor and director of the Robert D. Burch Center for Tax Policy and Public Finance at UC Berkeley, suggests that prospective retirees can forget the Social Security Administration-provided benefit calculations that come in the mail.
"They’re completely meaningless," says Auerbach. He says they simply don't factor in the implicit and explicit taxes that those ages 50 through 79 face from the offsets between income, age and benefits. Auerbach said the research highlights a need for much more transparency in the nation’s retirement and fiscal systems. The Social Security Administration could provide the information, he said, but likely needs a push to do so by "someone in government who thinks it's important." That someone, Auerbach suggested, could be in the presidential administration or in Congress.
Auerbach and his fellow researchers — Laurence Kotlifkoff, of Boston University and the Fiscal Analysis Center; Darryl Koehler, of Economic Security Planning Inc. and the Fiscal Analysis Center; and Manni Yu, of Boston University — did the math using data collected from older respondents to the Federal Reserve's 2013 Survey of Consumer Finances and special software they developed.
The Fiscal Analyzer incorporates all major federal and state fiscal programs — such as federal corporate income tax, personal federal and state income taxes, state sales taxes, estate taxes, Social Security benefits, food stamps, disability benefits, Medicare and Medicaid benefits and premiums and Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) taxes — and calculates remaining lifetime marginal net tax rates.
"We find that working longer, say an extra five years, can raise older workers' sustainable living standards," they report in their paper.
But the researchers report the impact is far smaller than suggested, in large part due to high net taxation of labor earnings. They also warn that many boomers now face or will face extremely high work disincentives arising from the hodgepodge and uncoordinated design of the nation's fiscal system.
"Our findings show that older workers typically face high, very high or remarkably high marginal net taxation on their extra earnings," they write, adding that work disincentives are highest for those at the bottom and top levels of resource distribution.
Don’t let the door hit you…
"Our findings suggest that Uncle Sam is, indeed, inducing the elderly to retire," they conclude. "Of particular concern is Medicaid and Social Security's complex earnings test and clawback of disability benefits," the researchers summarized. A clawback is the recovery of funds disbursed by a company, pension or government. "But an open question is the extent to which the elderly correctly perceive these disincentives," the report says. "Indeed … it's hard to believe that policymakers, themselves, are cognizant of the level and spread of the work disincentives they are imposing on the elderly."
The researchers found that the marginal net tax rate linked to a significant increase in retirement earnings, such as $20,000 a year from a part-time job, can for many elderly be "dramatically higher than that associated with earning a relatively small, say $1,000 a year, extra amount of money."
Pages: 1 · 2
- New Ammunition For An Appeal: Judge Accepts Medicare’s Plan To Remedy Misunderstanding On Therapy Coverage
- Janet Yellen Speaks at a Teachers Town Hall Meeting; The Gender Gap in Economics and the Leaky Pipeline Problem
- The Seasonal Tsunami of Senior Mail; No Longer a Pandora's Box
- Our Eyes Turn Towards the North: Senior Women in Canada
- Fact Tank: Voters Have Little Confidence Clinton or Trump Would Help Workers Get Skills They Need to Compete
- Liz Shuler, AFL-CIO's Secretary-Treasurer: Women and Work
- What Do You Know About Capturing End-of-Life Preferences in Electronic Health Records?
- Hearings on Zika and Campus Safety: Bills On Eliminating Pornography from Federal Computers, Opioid Use, Sexual Assault Survivors
- Helping High Schoolers Connect Degrees to Dollars: Engineering or Plumbing and Water Supplying?
- Beating the Brain Drain: States Focus on Retaining Older Workers; Finding Replacements Won’t Be Easy